Skip to content
Back to The Rest Is History
The Rest Is History artwork
Indexed 6 mentions

447. Custer vs. Crazy Horse: The Winning of the West (Part 2)

Summary, books mentioned, transcript quotes, and timestamps for 447. Custer vs. Crazy Horse: The Winning of the West (Part 2) on The Rest Is History.

Listen
Loading the embedded player…
Context before you listen

447. Custer vs. Crazy Horse: The Winning of the West (Part 2) mentions Custer by Ian Fraser, Custer and Crazy Horse by Stephen Ambrose, My Life on the Plains, and The Battle of the Washita River with timestamps, quotes, and episode context.

3 books from this episode
Custer
Ian Fraser

Custer's fame is the victory of fun and myth over complicated history.

Custer and Crazy Horse
Stephen Ambrose

Stephen Ambrose wrote a paired biography of Custer and Crazy Horse.

Custer also is very much a white supremacist, thinks in terms of race, but does also say, repeatedly in his autobiography, My Life on the Plains.

Episode summary
With the American Civil War coming to a close in April 1865, George Custer, cavalry commander in the Union army, and a man of dubious political leanings for a unionist officer, was sent to Texas. Reckless, daring and bloodthirsty, the conclusion of the war came as a disappointment to him. Then, having allied himself with the new, anti-Reconstruction American president, Andrew Johnson, Custer alienated himself from one of the most important men in the country: Ulysses S. Grant. As such he found himself exiled to the murderous but dull post of Kansas. There, he and the 7th Cavalry were charged with handling the looming conflict with the Cheyenne; an indigenous people of the Great Plains, whose lives and culture had been radically jeopardised by modernisation, and the encroachment of the railroads into their lands. While some Cheyenne were inclined to negotiate with Washington, their more zealous warriors, the ‘Dog Soldiers’, were determined to fight and destroy the settlers, sending bloodthirsty raids into federal forts. The campaigns that followed saw acts of terrific violence, culminating in a terrible, brutal massacre… Join Tom and Dominic as they discuss Custer’s first forays into the gruesome and tragic American Indian Wars: his political missteps, southern adventures, romantic rollercoasters, and battles with the remarkable horse-riding, buffalo hunting Cheyenne. EXCLUSIVE NordVPN Deal ➼ https://nordvpn.com/restishistory Try it risk-free now with a 30-day money-back guarantee! *The Rest Is History LIVE in 2024* Tom and Dominic are back onstage this summer, at Hampton Court Palace in London! Buy your tickets here: therestishistory.com Twitter: @TheRestHistory @holland_tom @dcsandbrook Producer: Theo Young-Smith Assistant Producer: Tabby Syrett
Mention timeline

Jump between the book moments.

View every mention
Custer
Ian Fraser

The host mentions the book 'Custer' by Ian Fraser to explore the complexities of Custer's character and the myth surr…

Card
Custer and Crazy Horse
Stephen Ambrose

The host mentions 'Custer and Crazy Horse' to highlight the complexities of Custer's actions during the Washita River…

Card
My Life on the Plains

The host discusses Custer's views on Native Americans as expressed in his autobiography, 'My Life on the Plains.' Thi…

Card
The Battle of the Washita River

The host discusses the controversial tactics used by Custer during the Battle of the Washita River, highlighting the…

Card
The Anatomy of Melancholy
Robert Burton

The host mentions 'The Anatomy of Melancholy' as a reflection of Custer's troubled mental state during a challenging…

Card
The West was not dull
Evan Connell

The host mentions Evan Connell's book to highlight the misconceptions surrounding the soldiers of the Indian wars. Co…

Card
Book mentions6
Media mentions1
Event size4
Quick answers

Quick FAQ

Answers to common summary, books, and takeaway questions for this episode.

What is 447. Custer vs. Crazy Horse: The Winning of the West (Part 2) about?

Summary, books mentioned, transcript quotes, and timestamps for 447. Custer vs. Crazy Horse: The Winning of the West (Part 2) on The Rest Is History.

What are the main takeaways from 447. Custer vs. Crazy Horse: The Winning of the West (Part 2)?

These are the strongest takeaways surfaced by the transcript, summary copy, and linked mentions for 447. Custer vs. Crazy Horse: The Winning of the West (Part 2).

  • The conversation centers on Custer's actions in warfare.
  • A second recurring theme is Custer's attitude towards Indians.
  • Referenced books include Custer by Ian Fraser and Custer and Crazy Horse by Stephen Ambrose.
  • The strongest audience signal points to History enthusiasts and those interested in military figures and Historians and readers interested in American history.

Which books are mentioned in 447. Custer vs. Crazy Horse: The Winning of the West (Part 2)?

Custer by Ian Fraser, Custer and Crazy Horse by Stephen Ambrose, and My Life on the Plains are the clearest linked books in this episode, each tied back to transcript timestamps and quote cards.

Why are listeners searching for 447. Custer vs. Crazy Horse: The Winning of the West (Part 2)?

447. Custer vs. Crazy Horse: The Winning of the West (Part 2) keeps attracting summary-style searches because this page combines episode context, transcript quotes, book references, and direct jump links back into the audio.

Topic and sentiment signals

Aggregated from transcript-derived mention metadata for better topical navigation and citation.

Mention sentiment
Critical Analysis(3)Passing Reference(2)Deep Dive(1)
Audience signals
History enthusiasts and those interested in military figuresHistorians and readers interested in American historyHistorians and those interested in American historyHistorians and students of American historyListeners interested in historical psychology

Books Mentioned

The full list below is ranked by how useful each mention is to a listener: stronger recommendation language, clearer quote context, and better timestamp support rise first.

Custer cover
Custer
Ian Fraser
Best for History enthusiasts and those interested in military figuresOften cited around Custer's life and myth

The speaker mentions reading a book about Custer while roaming the Great Plains, highlighting the appeal and myth surrounding Custer's character.

View mention details
Sentiment: Deep Dive
For: History enthusiasts and those interested in military figures
Key quote: Custer's fame is the victory of fun and myth over complicated history.
The host mentions the book 'Custer' by Ian Fraser to explore the complexities of Custer's character and the myth surrounding him. They aim to analyze whether Custer was truly as charming and lovable as often portrayed, contrasting this with the opinions of his superiors.
Direct Amazon listing · affiliate link
Check price
Custer and Crazy Horse cover
Custer and Crazy Horse
Stephen Ambrose
Best for Historians and readers interested in American historyOften cited around Custer's actions in warfare

Stephen Ambrose wrote a paired biography of Custer and Crazy Horse. He writes about the Weshita and says it's, you know, terrible slaughter.

View mention details
Sentiment: Critical Analysis
For: Historians and readers interested in American history
Key quote: Stephen Ambrose wrote a paired biography of Custer and Crazy Horse.
The host mentions 'Custer and Crazy Horse' to highlight the complexities of Custer's actions during the Washita River battle and the broader implications of U.S. expansionism. The book provides a nuanced perspective on Custer's role, suggesting that his actions were reflective of the era's moral ambiguities.
Direct Amazon listing · affiliate link
Check price
My Life on the Plains cover
Best for Historians and those interested in American historyOften cited around Custer's attitude towards Indians

Custer phrases his experiences in My Life on the Plains, describing the excitement of being chased and cornered, but does not express guilt about the deaths caused by his actions.

View mention details
Sentiment: Critical Analysis
For: Historians and those interested in American history
Key quote: Custer also is very much a white supremacist, thinks in terms of race, but does also say, repeatedly in his autobiography, My Life on the Plains.
The host discusses Custer's views on Native Americans as expressed in his autobiography, 'My Life on the Plains.' This mention serves to highlight the complexities and contradictions in Custer's character and the broader context of race relations during that era.
Direct Amazon listing · affiliate link
Check price
The Battle of the Washita River cover
Best for Historians and students of American historyOften cited around Custer's tactics at Washita

The Battle of the Washita River is the most complete and successful of all our private battles and was fought in such unfavorable weather and circumstances.

View mention details
Sentiment: Critical Analysis
For: Historians and students of American history
Key quote: If Custer was wrong, ultimately it was only because the nation was wrong, says Stiles.
The host discusses the controversial tactics used by Custer during the Battle of the Washita River, highlighting the moral implications of his actions. This leads to a broader examination of how Custer is perceived in historical narratives and the complexities surrounding the conflict with indigenous peoples.
Direct Amazon listing · affiliate link
Check price
The Anatomy of Melancholy cover
Best for Listeners interested in historical psychologyOften cited around Custer's mental state

Custer is trying to cheer himself up by reading The Anatomy of Melancholy by Robert Burton, which is described as a mad book to have taken on a frontier expedition.

View mention details
Sentiment: Passing Reference
For: Listeners interested in historical psychology
Key quote: he's trying to cheer himself up and he's trying to by reading the anatomy of melancholy by robert burton
The host mentions 'The Anatomy of Melancholy' as a reflection of Custer's troubled mental state during a challenging expedition. It serves to illustrate how Custer's choice of reading material contrasts with the harsh realities he faces, highlighting his descent into despair.
Direct Amazon listing · affiliate link
Check price
The West was not dull cover
Best for Historians and readers interested in American historyOften cited around Indian wars historiography

Evan Connell in his book says the West was not dull. It was stupendously dull. And when not dull, it was murderous.

View mention details
Sentiment: Passing Reference
For: Historians and readers interested in American history
Key quote: Evan Connell in his book says the West was not dull.
The host mentions Evan Connell's book to highlight the misconceptions surrounding the soldiers of the Indian wars. Connell's assertion that 'the West was not dull' serves to illustrate the chaotic and often grim realities faced by these soldiers.
Amazon search results · affiliate link
Find on Amazon
Weekly source-backed picks

Get the strongest books from new The Rest Is History episodes.

A short weekly email with transcript-backed book recommendations, source quotes, and exact moments from recently indexed episodes.

Custer
The Rest Is History · 2:01
Custer's fame is the victory of fun and myth over complicated history.
Custer and Crazy Horse
The Rest Is History · 56:34
Stephen Ambrose wrote a paired biography of Custer and Crazy Horse.
My Life on the Plains
The Rest Is History · 42:36
Custer also is very much a white supremacist, thinks in terms of race, but does also say, repeatedly in his autobiography, My Life on the Plains.
One useful email a week. Unsubscribe anytime.
Shop This Episode

Pick up the books after you hear them in context.

Custer cover
Mentioned at 2:01
Custer
Ian Fraser

The host mentions the book 'Custer' by Ian Fraser to explore the complexities of Custer's character and the myth surrounding him. They aim to analy…

Direct Amazon listing · affiliate link
Custer and Crazy Horse cover
Mentioned at 56:34
Custer and Crazy Horse
Stephen Ambrose

The host mentions 'Custer and Crazy Horse' to highlight the complexities of Custer's actions during the Washita River battle and the broader implic…

Direct Amazon listing · affiliate link
My Life on the Plains cover
Mentioned at 42:36
My Life on the Plains

The host discusses Custer's views on Native Americans as expressed in his autobiography, 'My Life on the Plains.' This mention serves to highlight…

Direct Amazon listing · affiliate link

Movies & Documentaries Mentioned

Movie

Little Big Man

Confidence: 90%

The film 'Little Big Man' is mentioned in relation to the Washita River battle and its portrayal of historical events.