Skip to content
Transcript-backed recommendation · Direct Amazon product page
Back to books
Why this book comes up
Book

mary poppins

P.L. Travers
Mentions3
Episodes3
Podcasts2

Listen before buying

mary poppins by P.L. Travers gets recommended on The Ezra Klein Show and The Rest Is History, including episode with Great American Storyteller, with transcript quotes, timestamps, and episode context.

mary poppins by P.L. Travers appears 3 times across 3 podcast episodes on 2 shows, with transcript quotes and timestamps.

he said, you know, the book is so much better than the movie.

Best episode to start with
Best Of: Why Adults Lose the ‘Beginner’s Mind’ on The Ezra Klein Show
Why people keep bringing this up

Both mentions come from episodes of The Ezra Klein Show, where a nine-year-old listener requests that a chapter from Mary Poppins be read aloud. The hosts reference the request twice across a best-of compilation and the original episode, emphasizing that the book is regarded by the child as “much better than the movie” and noting the text’s darker, stranger aspects.

These repeated references point to Mary Poppins being used as an illustrative example within conversations about perception and tone rather than as a focal book review. The specific detail that the child preferred the book to the film and highlighted its darker elements is what recurs across mentions, explaining why the title appears multiple times in episodes from the same podcast.

Recommendation signals

The host discusses P.L. Travers' critical view of Disney's adaptation of her book 'Mary Poppins'. Travers believed that Disney's approach would dilute the essence of her story, leading to a loss of its literary value.

The host mentioned 'Mary Poppins' as a cherished book that offers a much richer and darker perspective than its film adaptation. This recommendation came after a delightful experience reading it with his grandson, highlighting its appeal to older children.

The host mentions 'Mary Poppins' as a beloved children's book that offers a much richer experience than the film adaptation. They emphasize the book's surreal and darker elements, which provide a unique perspective on childhood adventures.

Best for
Readers interested in literary adaptations and cultural critiquesgrandparents and parents of older childrenParents and caregivers of children
Where it keeps coming up

Recent show rotation: The Ezra Klein Show and The Rest Is History.

Guests tied to these mentions include Great American Storyteller.

Fastest path back to the source: the strongest indexed mention lands at 1:00:35 in the episode where we captured it.

Quick answers

Quick FAQ

Answers to common book, episode, podcast, and guest questions.

Which episode recommended mary poppins?

Best Of: Why Adults Lose the ‘Beginner’s Mind’ on The Ezra Klein Show is one of the clearest indexed episodes that recommended mary poppins by P.L. Travers. Other indexed episodes include Why Adults Lose the ‘Beginner’s Mind’ on The Ezra Klein Show and 614. Walt Disney: The Great American Storyteller on The Rest Is History. The first indexed transcript timestamp lands at 1:00:35.

Which podcast mentioned mary poppins?

The Ezra Klein Show and The Rest Is History are the main indexed podcasts currently tied to mary poppins by P.L. Travers.

Who recommended mary poppins on podcasts?

Great American Storyteller is the main guest currently tied to recommending mary poppins by P.L. Travers.

Why do podcast guests bring up mary poppins?

The host discusses P.L. Travers' critical view of Disney's adaptation of her book 'Mary Poppins'. Travers believed that Disney's approach would dilute the essence of her story, leading to a loss of its literary value. It most often appears in conversations about P.L. Travers and Disney and children's book recommendations.

Source material

Mentions across episodes

Every mention card links back to the episode page and exact transcript anchor.

A nine-year-old requests to read a chapter from Mary Poppins, noting that the book is much better than the movie, highlighting the darker and stranger aspects of the character.

Sentiment: Highly Recommended
For: grandparents and parents of older children
Key quote: he said, you know, the book is so much better than the movie.
The host mentioned 'Mary Poppins' as a cherished book that offers a much richer and darker perspective than its film adaptation. This recommendation came after a delightful experience reading it with his grandson, highlighting its appeal to older children.

A nine-year-old requests to read a chapter from 'Mary Poppins', noting that the book is much better than the movie.

Sentiment: Highly Recommended
For: Parents and caregivers of children
Key quote: he said, you know, the book is so much better than the movie.
The host mentions 'Mary Poppins' as a beloved children's book that offers a much richer experience than the film adaptation. They emphasize the book's surreal and darker elements, which provide a unique perspective on childhood adventures.

P.L. Travers described Disney's adaptation of her most famous novel, Mary Poppins, as coarse and wrong in every way, reflecting her disdain for the changes made in the script.

Sentiment: Critical Analysis
For: Readers interested in literary adaptations and cultural critiques
Key quote: She believed that Disney had replaced elements of truth and insight central to her books with a saccharine sentimentality.
The host discusses P.L. Travers' critical view of Disney's adaptation of her book 'Mary Poppins'. Travers believed that Disney's approach would dilute the essence of her story, leading to a loss of its literary value.