Skip to content
Back to books
Book signal map
Book

bad therapy

Abigail Schreier
Mentions9
Episodes7
Podcasts2

Why listeners keep surfacing bad therapy

bad therapy by Abigail Schreier appears 9 times across 7 podcast episodes on 2 shows, with transcript quotes and timestamps.

Recent mentions on Modern Wisdom and Joe Rogan Experience.

Abigail Shrier's book, "Bad Therapy: Why Kids Aren't Growing Up," has gained significant attention across various podcast episodes, particularly on the Joe Rogan Experience and Modern Wisdom. The discussions often center around the book's critique of therapy culture for children, with guests like JD Vance and Bessel van der Kolk referencing its insights on mental health treatment in the United States. Vance specifically highlights the book's relevance in the context of growing concerns about mental health issues, while van der Kolk acknowledges Shrier's contributions to the conversation on therapeutic practices.

The book's themes resonate with other contemporary discussions, as noted by Eric Weinstein, who expresses disagreement with Shrier's ideas, indicating that her work is sparking debate among thought leaders. The frequency of mentions, including Shrier's own appearance on the Joe Rogan Experience, underscores the book's impact and the ongoing relevance of its message regarding the challenges facing today's youth in therapeutic settings.

Recommendation signals

The host mentions 'Bad Therapy' by Abigail Schreier to highlight the ongoing skepticism surrounding therapy practices. This book serves as a critique of the current state of therapy, emphasizing the need for therapists to engage in their own therapeutic processes.

The host mentions 'Bad Therapy' to critique the prevailing therapy culture, especially as it pertains to children. They highlight the potential negative effects of excessive self-reflection and the importance of focusing on broader missions for happiness.

The host mentions 'Bad Therapy' by Abigail Shryer to express their fundamental disagreement with the book's ideas. They highlight the challenge of addressing uncomfortable topics in therapy while acknowledging the value of evidence-based interventions like CBT.

Best for
Mental health professionals and individuals interested in therapyParents and mental health professionalsIndividuals interested in therapy and critical discussions about mental health.Listeners interested in cultural critiques and generational discussions.
Where it keeps coming up

Recent show rotation: Modern Wisdom and Joe Rogan Experience.

Guests tied to these mentions include Naval Ravikant, JD Vance, Eric Weinstein, and Bessel van der Kolk.

Fastest path back to the source: the first indexed mention lands at 52:43 in the episode where we captured it.

bad therapy cover
Buy This Book
bad therapy
Buy
Source material

Mentions across episodes

Every mention card links back to the episode page and exact transcript anchor.

Abigail Schreier was on the show, and she wrote this book called Bad Therapy, sort of pushing back against therapy culture for kids, specifically for kids.

Sentiment: Critical Analysis
For: Parents and mental health professionals
Key quote: there is like basically a direct correlation between how much you think about yourself and how miserable you are.
The host mentions 'Bad Therapy' to critique the prevailing therapy culture, especially as it pertains to children. They highlight the potential negative effects of excessive self-reflection and the importance of focusing on broader missions for happiness.
Transcript mentionJump to mention

The mental health thing in here in the United States is really, really worrisome. Have you read this book, Bad Therapy? No. Okay. It's good. I've heard it. It's good. Yeah, I haven't read it though.

Sentiment: Passing Reference
For: Individuals interested in mental health and veterans' issues
Key quote: Have you read this book, Bad Therapy? No. Okay. It's good.
The host mentions 'Bad Therapy' in the context of discussing the mental health challenges faced by veterans returning from war. They highlight the need for better mental health treatment and express concern over the current state of mental health care in the United States.

The speaker mentions the book 'Bad Therapy' in the context of discussing mental health issues and treatment in the United States.

Sentiment: Passing Reference
For: Individuals interested in mental health solutions
Key quote: Have you read this book, Bad Therapy? No. Okay. It's good.
The host mentions 'Bad Therapy' in the context of discussing the mental health challenges faced by veterans returning from war. They highlight the inadequacies of the current mental health system and suggest that the book addresses these issues, although the host has not read it yet.

The speaker discusses their disagreement with the ideas presented in Abigail Shryer's book 'Bad Therapy' and their approach to addressing it in a podcast episode.

Sentiment: Critical Analysis
For: Individuals interested in therapy and critical discussions about mental health.
Key quote: I fundamentally disagreed with a lot of the ideas in it.
The host mentions 'Bad Therapy' by Abigail Shryer to express their fundamental disagreement with the book's ideas. They highlight the challenge of addressing uncomfortable topics in therapy while acknowledging the value of evidence-based interventions like CBT.

Abigail Schreier recently wrote a book called Bad Therapy. She went on Joe's show. She came on this show.

Sentiment: Critical Analysis
For: Mental health professionals and individuals interested in therapy
Key quote: There's a lot of criticism and skepticism at the moment about therapy and therapy culture.
The host mentions 'Bad Therapy' by Abigail Schreier to highlight the ongoing skepticism surrounding therapy practices. This book serves as a critique of the current state of therapy, emphasizing the need for therapists to engage in their own therapeutic processes.

Abigail Schreier, Bad Therapy. She wrote a book. Everyone's kind of keen about it because it's in the same ballpark as Jonathan Haidt's book and Gene Twenge's book.

Sentiment: Critical Analysis
For: Listeners interested in cultural critiques and generational discussions.
Key quote: Perfect example of this, Abigail Schreier, Bad Therapy.
The host mentions 'Bad Therapy' by Abigail Schreier as a critique of the fragility of Gen Z, linking it to broader discussions about cultural influences like screens and smartphones. He expresses disagreement with some of Schreier's views, indicating a desire for more challenging conversations on his show.

Your new book, Bad Therapy: Why Kids Aren't Growing Up.

Sentiment: Critical Analysis
For: Parents and mental health professionals
Key quote: They're giving it to kids who aren't sick, who aren't actually struggling with mental illness or a disorder.
The host discusses the implications of therapy on children and how it can sometimes exacerbate existing issues rather than help. The mention of the book 'Bad Therapy: Why Kids Aren't Growing Up' serves to highlight the author's perspective on the potential harms of therapy when applied to children who may not actually need it.

The discussion revolves around the book 'Bad Therapy' and its message about the ineffectiveness of certain therapeutic practices and the importance of trusting parental instincts.

Sentiment: Critical Analysis
For: Parents and mental health professionals
Key quote: They're giving it to kids who aren't sick, who aren't actually struggling with mental illness or a disorder.
The host discusses the implications of therapy on children and teens, referencing the book 'Bad Therapy' to highlight the potential harms of therapy when applied to those who may not actually need it. The conversation emphasizes the difference in therapy dynamics between adults and minors, suggesting that the latter may be more susceptible to negative outcomes.

Abigail Schreier is mentioned as someone who has talked about the issue of transgender identity and its implications.

Sentiment: Deep Dive
For: Parents and educators concerned about youth identity issues
Key quote: Abigail Schreier has experienced a tremendous amount of that.
The host discusses the implications of social pressures on young people's identities, particularly in relation to gender. Abigail Schreier's work is highlighted as a significant contribution to understanding these dynamics and the potential consequences for youth.